Who's on Third

Viv Park 3 months ago

Thomas was our amazing server for the night. Really liked his laid back, but friendly and helpful demeanor, as well as his professionalism in accommodating our needs. Made our experience super easy and perfectly pleasant. Grilled wings Ooh, these were perfectly grilled. Very tasty sauce (hot honey garlic, at Thomas’ recommendation) that wasn’t overdone or underdone - just the right amount. I usually get my wings naked because so many places go wrong with the amount of sauce (usually just too drenched), but since we were on a timeline tonight, we just ordered without asking for anything else. So glad we did! By the way, not fried wings, so not super crunchy on the outside but still crispy and not at all soggy. And super moist, perfect temp inside. Tap Guinness Perfectly poured with just the right amount of cream on top. Hany is usually an IPA man, and went Guinness this time and did not regret it! Overall, this place is a little bit further away than the new hopping bars on the Deer District. I wanted to try the new places, so kept on trying them while hubby wanted to keep coming back here… and I’m glad we did this time. Sometimes new is good, but they’ve got it right here - I don’t have to keep searching! Oh just one thing - all the TVs in the bar, and they have to play 60 minutes? Without captions? lol

Joe Penn 3 months ago

Came for the grilled wings and they did not disappoint! Sriracha Ginger and the classic hot were a hit. Loved the sweet potato fries, great way to soften the heat from the gumbo. Chef Ali, Sam, and Taylor made it a great experience - I'll be back to try the other wing flavors and a brat (or three). I went on a game night which explains the crowd but thankfully everything came out quick and the bartenders were prompt with keeping my glass full.

Jason Schulte a month ago

We stopped here as we were spending some time downtown Milwaukee. We walked by and wanted to try it. I had a black and blue burger. It was really tasty, but I didin't get a lot of blackened with it. Still, it was really good if you like that kind of thing. My wife had a cob salad and enjoyed it to the last bite. We also had and order of a cheese curds. I can say they did those right, they were amazing. My one complaint is they find ways to add all kinds of charges. You want ranch you are going to pay extra. You want to use a credit card, you are going to pay a few. When you are paying $9.00 for a basket of fries, you would think they could throw in a little ranch. Overall, it was a beautiful day to have a really good lunch out.

TM Demko a year ago

Stopped in for lunch before going to Chano’s Warehouse next door. Staff was super friendly. Tasty St Patty’s cocktails. I had a burger which was exactly what you hope a bar burger would taste like. Greasy, flavorful and delicious. My friend had chicken tenders in a yummy tempura type breading. We had cheese curds for appetizers…. Yum! Prices are spot on in my opinion. Food was great. Cocktails were great. Excellent service.

Robert Bilkie 2 months ago

In town from Detroit for a few days of business meetings and stumbled into Who’s on Third—what a great find. The beer selection is outstanding, with plenty of options whether you’re in the mood for something local or just a solid classic. The food was just as impressive—well above what you’d expect from a bar. What really made the experience stand out, though, was the service. Avery behind the bar is a fantastic host—engaging, sharp, and genuinely interesting to talk to. You can tell they enjoy what they do, and it elevates the whole atmosphere. If you’re in Milwaukee, whether for work or just passing through, this place is absolutely worth a stop.